Dear Rchammer,
Despite what your father says (and remember, Dads always know best) a strange thing about models is that to represent gloss on the real boat, you need to use satin paint on your model, and to represent satin or matt, you need to use matt paint. To represent a seasoned boat as you do, I think matt paint would be best.
But remember, if you ask 5 model boaters a question, you will get 7 different answers!
best of luck!
Chris