Bottom line is, there will be members on this forum who lurk and offer nothing towards the site be it comments or help...
I feel that's a little unfair to many 'quiet' members - not everyone feels confident enough to pipe up on an open forum.
I'll agree with you so far as there must be some great modellers out there who could join in but don't for one reason or another.

But I think we all have to recognise that sometimes a newbie gets off on the wrong foot here and just gets shot down in flames.
Sometimes we could just be more tolerant. And to be honest rivet counters can
sometimes get a raw deal too......... and maybe that's
exactly why some good and knowledgeable modellers simply keep quiet?
Dave