Hi Pointy,
Firstly, if the varnish makes the finish look like an old vase then that is an effect.
If the varnish has caused this then that has had an affect, hope this helps.
Secondly, is it possible that the Halfords and the Plasticote are incompatible? e.g. are they both cellulose paints? For what its worth I sprayed my YORKSHIREMAN with Halfords clear lacquer and had the same problem in those areas I had painted using humbrol enamels such as the cappings and towbow although the effect is only apparent on areas painted matt black and of these, only those areas painted with paint from a different batch.
I sympathise, it must be soul destroying to see all your work not turning out as you wished. Maybe one of our number who is an experienced car sprayer/paint specialist can help
Tom
Keep on steaming