Model Boat Mayhem

Technical, Techniques, Hints, and Tips => Radio Equipment => Topic started by: old shrimper on January 24, 2013, 07:01:54 am

Title: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on January 24, 2013, 07:01:54 am
hi guys
i need a recommendation for a servo about 20 mm high   ( brand part # ) the one i ordered is way to high its about 50mm
has to handle a rudder 55 m x 30m with a  60m prop and 540 MFA on 6.1 using 6V
thanks bob
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: colin on January 24, 2013, 07:28:54 am
Probably a silly answer but can you mount it on side and still link up.


Colin
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on January 24, 2013, 08:38:33 am
i could but it looks messy, i wanted to re sees it through the aft lower deck in the center  but the keel comes up to high in that section to be able use the  servo i have
if i move it to next section the control arm becomes about 6" long ( not sure that's a good idea ?)  in the pic its hard to due to glare of the 2 pack resin , but in foreground is the deck with the rudder tube  then there is a slot cut in bulk head
and the deck continues  on the other side ALL this is closed over  for ever when its finished
if i go to next section i still have to cut about 10 m out of the keel to get it lower enough for the control arm to line up
can you link me to some pic of the servo fitted in some models ?

http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/MODEL%20BOAT%20PIC/DSC00957_zpsfc515992.jpg

http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/MODEL%20BOAT%20PIC/DSC00956_zps62aa067e.jpg
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: colin-d on January 24, 2013, 10:11:58 am
Hi Bob,
 
you want to be looking for Low Profile Servos..... there are quite a few out there on the market, usually a bit more expensive that the normal servos..
 
i used one of these on my SS Furie build... (BlueBird BMS-706MG)
 
hope this helps..
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: RAAArtyGunner on January 24, 2013, 10:49:04 am
 
 
Bob,
 
Is it possible to cut out portion, say rectangular shape, of the cross member near the rudder.
It would need to be large enough, to allow lining up with your servo and rudder, as per Colin's photo
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: AlanT on January 24, 2013, 11:02:32 am
I know your problem well just having come up against it during my Lindberg Fletcher Destroyer build, which has a very low stern area. I also don't like to lie the servo down, prefering the upright position.
 
I always like to use HiTec Servos, and as well as their standard servo they do an excellent Micro Servo which is 20mm high. There are other cheaper Micro Servo's around, especially on Ebay but I've never had a great deal of success with them.
 
Available almost anywhere. This is the code for it :- HS430BH HV Mini Sero Ref: 4504 You will find this code probably relates to a large model shop in Poole.
 
Regards
 
Alan
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: colin-d on January 24, 2013, 12:30:14 pm
the HS430BH is a High voltage servo.... 6v-7.4v  not the normal 4.8v-6v
 
Quote
Micro Servo which is 20mm high

the dimentions are not realy that much smaller, Size in Millimetres -(L.W.H) 40.60 x 19.80 x 36.60 (high)
 
most Low Profile servos are about 20-25mm High..
 
 


Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: inertia on January 24, 2013, 12:58:29 pm
I suggest mounting a standard servo as close as you can and then routing the connection to the tiller arm via a flexible tube-inside-a-tube arrangement. Aircraft modellers call them "snakes". Example of these is here http://www.slecuk.com/catalogue/Snakes.html (http://www.slecuk.com/catalogue/Snakes.html)
You'll not require a connection to both sides of the tiller arm; one will be enough with a slow model like this will be.
Suit yourself, but I'd give up on hunting for a servo that low in profile if I were you.
DM
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: AlanT on January 24, 2013, 07:16:39 pm
Sorry wrong link selected....This is the Servo I used:-Hitec 55. Cost around £10 -
Alan
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: malcolmfrary on January 24, 2013, 08:14:01 pm
To move a large rudder I would not consider using any sort of Mini or Micro servo.  Low profile types with the right spec seem OK, but are likely to cost.  If the servo is to be mounted out of sight, it doesn't matter which way it is facing, all that really matters is that movement of the stick gives a corresponding movement of the rudder.  Using a snake is good, or a  rigid rod (a shark trace wire can be stiffened using a splint).  6" is no problem for the shark trace - I've had that arrangement on yachts for years.
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 13, 2013, 10:26:20 am
(http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/MODEL%20BOAT%20PIC/DSC01566.jpg)
(http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/MODEL%20BOAT%20PIC/DSC01565.jpg)


(http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/MODEL%20BOAT%20PIC/DSC01564.jpg)


hi guys i need some info on this set up as you can see the clives bind up before the servo gets to it switch off point ( i think anyway ) there is enough rudder movement about 35% do do the job but will it burn out out or damage the servo not being able to go the full travel
thanks for any help cheers Bob
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: hdserv on February 13, 2013, 10:42:43 am
use a ball joint
 ball screws onto servo arm cup for the ball onto push rod
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: malcolmfrary on February 13, 2013, 11:39:14 am
The redneck engineering answer is to provide clearance by filing away the offending bit of arm at each end. 
Personally, I've never bothered with a clevis, putting a Z bend in the wire has always done the job OK.  My rudder links are usually two part - the rudder one overshoots the servo and is supported by the servo arm, the servo link goes forward and is connected to the rudder link using a "choc bloc" electric connector.  Simple, robust, reliable and allows for easy tracking adjustment.  Probably comes from my habit of making my own tiller arms from the brass bits of dead mains plugs.
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: sailorboy61 on February 13, 2013, 01:08:02 pm
Use a linkage stopper on the servo arm so the tiller rod sits above and doesn't foul?
 
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 14, 2013, 12:12:02 am
can you guys link me to some pics of a   Z BEND , A mini BALL JOINT ,( and were to by them ) and a LINKAGE STOPPER ?
is it possible to reset the micro switch in the servo to stop it going as far ?


as yet i don't have the raido TX / RX can i just connect the  +   6v to  one of the 3 wires on the servo lead and the -  to one of the other 3 wires to make it work ?
thanks Bob



Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: Tug-Kenny RIP on February 16, 2013, 10:39:29 am

It's not really a good idea to connect a servo direct to a battery. There may be a chance it's fully charged to over 6 volts and the servos are designed to run at less than 6 volts. Also worth noting is the fact that a direct voltage will drive the servo motor continuously against it end stop !!!

Another thing which is not normally possible is to adjust the set stop to reduce travel.  All in all, you are damaging the servo.

A  "Z"  bend is merely a bend in the linkage wire in the shape of a "Z".  This allows the wire to bend if it is obstructed in any way.

Hope this is helpful

Ken
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 16, 2013, 11:02:26 am
hi Kenny
thanks for the heads up on the servo i will get a TX/RX set before i try it out
 
will the ESC drop the voltage from 12 v to the correct voltage for the servo ?


i will make up a Z bend linkage to morrow i have plenty  of 2m rods
cheers Bob
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on February 16, 2013, 11:16:35 am
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=370760924561 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=370760924561)
here are the ball joints you are looking for :-))
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: inertia on February 16, 2013, 11:40:03 am
If your setting-up procedure so far hasn't involved powering up the servo then I think you are worrying unduly. All servos can be made to move that far simply by turning the output arm by hand, but under power they rarely move over 45 degrees each way (often less than that). Buy the radio and see how far the servo moves before you convince yourself there is actually a problem. BTW no modern servo contains a microswitch; they are a little more sophisticated than that! Connecting them directly to a battery as you suggest will not prompt any movement at all. That's what the third wire is for - you don't need to know anything further, just don't do it.
Ball joints are always a good idea in that there is absolutely no backlash (slop) in the linkage and you can take off almost 180 degrees of drive before the servo arm overlocks.
Many speed controllers are equipped with BEC (Battery Eliminator Circuity). This takes the voltage from the main motor drive battery and reduces it to a safe level to operate the receiver and servos etc. Just make sure that you buy this type. Personally I prefer to use a separate battery pack for the receiver wherever possible.
DM
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: malcolmfrary on February 16, 2013, 12:28:06 pm
The Z bend in my case is a shape in the end of the wire linkage to go through the tiller arm, which I usually get from filing and drilling a bit of brasswork from a dead 13 amp mains plug (too tight to actually buy "proper" model stuff).  Slop is minimal, and I have never had a problem.  The wire from my tiller arm is usually set to overshoot the servo arm - another similar wire goes from the servo arm and connects to the tiller wire using an electric choc bloc connector.  Simple, self supporting and allows for easy adjustment.  However, you have your clevises, they are designed to work, just stick with them.
When you get the radio, a good idea would be to not have the servo arm fitted initially.  Turn it all on, let the servo find its centre position, then fit the arm.
Quote
will the ESC drop the voltage from 12 v to the correct voltage for the servo ?
If the ESC has a label saying "BEC", yes.  Powering up a servo without a valid signal will cause it to twitch a bit, and if repeated will eventually cause the servo to get to the end of its travel, probably way beyond where it will ever go in service.  Yet another reason why the TX should be switched on before the RX.
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 17, 2013, 02:28:46 am
HI GUYS thanks for info so far
this is a page shot of the controller im getting for $40 with RX unit they have good reviews on rc forums http://www.ultimaterc.com/forums/showthread.php?t=117089
where it says E POINT ( END POSITION ) is that the steering limit so you can adjust the amount of rudder / wheels movement
and what is expertenchel  (EXP ) do we use it ?
need some coaching here , i have no idea what im getting in to
has any one USED one of these ??


(http://i1266.photobucket.com/albums/jj529/atomicmaloo/Untitled.jpg)
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: AlisterL on February 17, 2013, 03:46:05 am
EXP on a radio refers to an exponential rate of movement. Rather than being truly proportional with the movement of the sticks (or wheel and trigger) on the transmitter, with EXP enabled the rate of change of movement of the arm increases the further you move. In theory it give you more precise control on smaller movements I guess.
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 17, 2013, 03:58:48 am
 hi mate
thanks for that info its not something i would use i guess ? i wont small rudder movement with large amount of wheel
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on February 17, 2013, 09:28:51 am
hi.i use these on all my power boats,they are great,it has a small switch on the handle where you can adjust the amount of movement on the rudder servo when going,great for setting up at speed,it also has trim adjustment,end adjustment and more, :-))
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 17, 2013, 10:40:06 am
hi mate
good to here they are OK can i call on you for some set up advice when it gets here ?
cheers Bob

Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on February 17, 2013, 05:08:53 pm
no probs :-))
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on February 18, 2013, 07:01:51 am
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=370760924561 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=370760924561)
here are the ball joints you are looking for :-))


im realy struggling to find some where that actually post them to Australia it says they post world wide , then when you go to the cart it says DONT POST to about 20 countries
OZ is one of them  >:-o >>:-(
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: RAAArtyGunner on February 18, 2013, 08:29:12 am

im realy struggling to find some where that actually post them to Australia it says they post world wide , then when you go to the cart it says DONT POST to about 20 countries
OZ is one of them  >:-o >>:-(

I know, best to forget all about UK based suppliers etc and source them from Hong Kong or the US as they post world wide plus you won't be ripped of by being charged the VAT (20% tax the local's pay) from which we are exempt.
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on March 06, 2013, 01:47:02 am
hi.i use these on all my power boats,they are great,it has a small switch on the handle where you can adjust the amount of movement on the rudder servo when going,great for setting up at speed,it also has trim adjustment,end adjustment and more, :-))


hi mate
my FS GT3 arrived yesterday  :}  i have it working  :-))  [size=78%], had to do REV on servo setting as it was [/size]steering[size=78%] the wrong way,and had to set the ESC up as it was running at full noise [/size]
with out pulling the triger, then i thought i "xxxxx" it up as it blew the 5amp fuse i had in the line from the batt put a 15amp one all good (its a 25 amp viper ESC )


then i was playing round with the settings trying to slow the steering down and lost servo movement for about an hour till i figgered out  i had turned it down to much  :embarrassed:


i then but the model in the pool for a run .
i find the steering to direct , can i adjust the amount travel relevant to the amount of wheel ?
and the rev trigger(pushing it away from you with yer finger ) does go in REV but if you push the triger all the way to the stop it cuts the motor out can i adjust the stop out
thanks for any help
PS how long do the 8x AA BATT last in the controller i put 8 new ones in and after about 2 hours setting it up they were down 10v ?
i will use rechargeable ones from now on   

Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: Tug-Kenny RIP on March 06, 2013, 02:03:35 pm

Hi Shrimper.

I have put your reply  outside of the quotes.

When replying and using a  QUOTE  be sure to start typing after the  Not quote sign.

This message will self destruct after being read.    {-)

Ken

Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on March 06, 2013, 03:52:23 pm
hi.on the handle there is 2 switches.the top one will adjust the throw on the steering,move it forward for more back for less,when you find the ideal setting remember to lock it in by press the big button on the top and then the right smaller one then the left smaller one that locks in the settings,failing to do this everytime you switch the handset of it goes back to the old settings if not lock in,abit of a pain i know bvut easy when you have done it a few times,there are end point movement in the display screen for all channels,play about with these just try and remember where there are now so you can go back to them,if you havent locked them in then just turn the handset of and back on and it will go back to the old settings,hope this helps? regards kurt %%
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on March 06, 2013, 03:52:36 pm
i use rechargeable ones and they last almost all day :-))
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on March 06, 2013, 11:53:00 pm
hi
i gather you are referring to the button marked DR ? what does  duel range mean
it does reduce the amount of rudder ,but i need the full amount of rudder to maneuver  the boat ,just not all at ounce
 


does your handset cut out in REVERSE if you push the trigger out to far??


thanks for the tip on locking the settings in
thanks Bob
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: black magic racing on March 06, 2013, 11:58:46 pm
hi bob,i use mine on petrol power boats mate ,and am still learning,we dont have a reverse we set it up to cut the engine ,sorry i cant be of much more help,if i figure anything else out i will let you know,regards kurt :-))
Title: Re: HELP WITH CHOOSING A SERVO
Post by: old shrimper on March 07, 2013, 12:02:48 am
ok no worries
thanks