Model Boat Mayhem
Mess Deck: General Section => Model Boating => Topic started by: jaymac on May 01, 2014, 10:04:11 am
-
Help please what would be the best way to repair this damage .I think replacement is a no no so which glue perhaps bearing in mind its locationand vibration . The parts seem to go back together at the break Thanks
(http://i152.photobucket.com/albums/s161/jaymac_port/AFramedamage_zps160035b9.jpg) (http://s152.photobucket.com/user/jaymac_port/media/AFramedamage_zps160035b9.jpg.html)
-
I would use epoxy resin and fit a long narrow screw down through from the inside.
Ken
-
jaymac........along similar lines to Ken......is this a triple prop?........how many A frames are sheared?....... some major surgery may be required in the stern deck area for access
1. assemble the sheared A frame assemblies to the hull
2. lightly tack weld each joint back together with a Superglue
3. select a reinforcement size brass dowels.........1/16".....1/8"..?
3. drill down into each arm of each A frame component with the respective size for size of the dowel
4. spiral flute the trimmed dowels & insert with a compatible epoxy glue
5. after the curing, gouge the external joint fracture area in each leg & repair with the appropriate fillers etc :-))
Derek
-
Thanks both and just two frames/ props both sheared Derek methinks just gluing is about my max skill I don think there is enough meat use a screw there appears to be a bit of metal wire showing which may have been some kind of pin . If I could get hold of the italeri build manual it might show if they are pre or post attached to the hull the deck I believe is removable(screws)
Thanks again
Jay
-
Jay,
Yes the deck should be attached with screws supplied in the kit.
The "A" frames from memory are attached by 'plastic' pin extensions.
-
Thanks Raaarty thats where they broke off it seems bloody parcel force
Jay
-
Your welcome, O0 O0
It should be possible to glue them back, the plastic pins can be replaced with metal such as brass railing etc
Another 'trick' is to melt some of the kit plastic with glue to make a putty and spread it around the join it will reinforce and help glue them in place.
One of the guys building plastic "tank' kits may have more detail on how it is done. The 'putty can also be used as a filler and will harden as part of the section it is applied to and can be sanded etc.
Good luck.
-
Thanks
Jay
-
OK got the deck offf and now can see from beneath any drilling/pinning is a no no for me so which would the best glue be easily obtainable brand just epoxy means squat to me
-
If brass pinning and drilling is not what you are up to, and nothing wrong with that, then I would suggest if the part fixed to the lower hull is hollow and the part that is broken hollow then a either: a plastic lollipop stick, or other small round rod instead of a brass rod. As for epoxy, you want a two part epoxy, get a good quality one. Mix up and then with the hull upside down add the epoxy into the broken hollow section, insert the rod (this is for added strength) then you need to add epoxy to the broken lower part and seal together, try and not get any air-bubbles as this will add weak areas. Wipe around the broken seam to make sure that the epoxy seals the area good. Leave to dry for 48 hrs so that it is well cured before lightly sanding the epoxy to shape-shouldn't need much just to tidy up prior to painting-use masking tape to mask off the hull, props etc just leaving the A-frame-now use a good primer and spray lightly-once cured 24hrs, touch up with paint. Make sure the A-frame is aligned correctly prior to fixing.
Si:)
-
Thanks but they are solid
-
if they are the same plastic as the hull, then simple plastiweld liquid poli glue will "weld" them together. neil.
-
if they are the same plastic as the hull, then simple plastiweld liquid poli glue will "weld" them together. neil.
Plastiweld is a plastic cement which the instructions say to use under useful advice
-
Thanks guys dont know if the same plastic but would think probably .Raarty did you you have to Glue the Aframe as well as the pins
Also is plasti weld available under other names
Thanks
-
Try this one,
-
Thanks guys dont know if the same plastic but would think probably .Raarty did you you have to Glue the Aframe as well as the pins
Also is plasti weld available under other names
Thanks
There is a member here, local to you, Star Loc adhesives who has Plastic cements. Polystyrene glue is a plastic cement and made by Revel and Testors.
Yes, you glue the entire item the pins are only for locating the item and in my opinion shear off due to their design the 'glued base' is the strength.
Plastic cement literally melts the two surfaces together that is why they say don't use too much as it will dissolve the plastic, AKA polystyrene. This is the realm of plastic kit making which our Resident Tamiya tank poster is well versed.
-
Here is the link to his tank thread, a personal message would get you some local assitance
http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,47300.msg478772/topicseen.html#msg478772 (http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,47300.msg478772/topicseen.html#msg478772)
-
Here is the link to his tank thread, a personal message would get you some local assitance
http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,47300.msg478772/topicseen.html#msg478772 (http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,47300.msg478772/topicseen.html#msg478772)
I'm here... :-)
Right, so we have a 1/35 scale S-boat with broken A-frames. As you cannot drill and pin then option I would use is CA glue (Cyanoacrylate) a thin variety, they do a medium and thick but they maybe too thick. Get a good quality one.
Clean the area of the break and just around the edges so you get a good clean bond-the thinner the glue you will get more capillary action as it runs into the joins. A good tip is one the area has set, you can lightly score around the original break, not too much and then mix some of the CA glue with baking powder/soda (sodium bicarbonate) the glue and the powder mix makes a super and very strong filler, apply in the the grove and then just lightly sand to shape-touch up with paint.
The advantages of using a good quality CA glue are that it bonds better and is also water resistant.
Si:)
-
Sorry to disagree Eddie,
but a solvent weld using Plasticweld for Polystyrene, (assuming the plastic is polystyrene) when done properly will have the same strength as the parent plastic.
CA is only as strong as the bond it has to the plastic, which in most cases will be less than the strength of the plastic.
I do a lot of 3D printing using ABS, and the only "glue" I use is Acetone, and buy it in 500ml containers, for less than the price of a tube of "plastiweld"
I apply it with a toothpick or a small clean brush. Put the parts together, apply the brush(charged with acetone), and the solvent wicks in. Keep the parts clamped together, so there is some pressure to keep the two faces together and 48 hours later you have virtually one part again.
My recomendation would be the same as RAAArtyGunner, use "plastiweld or some other SOLVENT plastic "glue" which are formulated for the type of Styrene used in plastic kitsets.
Hope this is of some help
cheers
vnkiwi :-))
-
Sorry to disagree Eddie,
but a solvent weld using Plasticweld for Polystyrene, (assuming the plastic is polystyrene) when done properly will have the same strength as the parent plastic.
CA is only as strong as the bond it has to the plastic, which in most cases will be less than the strength of the plastic.
I do a lot of 3D printing using ABS, and the only "glue" I use is Acetone, and buy it in 500ml containers, for less than the price of a tube of "plastiweld"
I apply it with a toothpick or a small clean brush. Put the parts together, apply the brush(charged with acetone), and the solvent wicks in. Keep the parts clamped together, so there is some pressure to keep the two faces together and 48 hours later you have virtually one part again.
My recomendation would be the same as RAAArtyGunner, use "plastiweld or some other SOLVENT plastic "glue" which are formulated for the type of Styrene used in plastic kitsets.
Hope this is of some help
cheers
vnkiwi :-))
As this boat is going on water (I think) then the use of CA using also a CA filler, in my mind, seemed the best option. However, having read your post and had a good think you are correct-I have used Acetone in builds and to be honest you have to get it right or you can make a mess-so this maybe not be the best option, in this case. As for plastic weld, either liquid or two part epoxy would/should do the job. One thing I would be tempted is to cut down a sliver of plastic from an old box or carton and glue that into the hollow areas just give more strength.
Si:)
-
Thanks againguys yes Eddie she is going on the water . There are no Hollows to fillin just rough surface where it sheared .I will porobably give the plast weld ago.Am toying with a slip of thin brass strip or plasticard on the inside glued on the inside of the legs . Nice tank never saw one in that condition in my day not even the centurions :}
Jay
-
This any good or any below it looking at maybe getting something local
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Devcon-Plastic-Welder-Syringe-G-S220/dp/B004RNWA0Y/ref=wl_mb_wl_huc_mrai_2_dp#productDetails (http://www.amazon.co.uk/Devcon-Plastic-Welder-Syringe-G-S220/dp/B004RNWA0Y/ref=wl_mb_wl_huc_mrai_2_dp#productDetails)
-
go to your local builders merchant and get some plastic pipe cleaner the LIQUID one NOT the adhesive same stuff as plastic weld use a small modeling paint brush or cocktail stick tins are around 250ml wil last a lot longer and you cant knock it over likr the small bottles
Dave
-
Well Plastic weld no work one came apart without being near the water Done again both came off in the water . I thought perhaps the shafts might be slightly warped puttting to much strain .Though that might well be the case Plastic weld would not even hold the centre rudder together and thats two vertical leafs with no stress Back to the drawing board
-
Extreme surgery, I know, but could you not fit a pair of brass A frames from the likes of George Sitek? Once correctly lined up and epoxied into position the whole assembly would be very strong and very unlikely to give any future problems.
David.
-
Many thanks David for the link If push comes to shove may consider that though doubt I would be able to work out what s needed
Thanks
Jay
-
heres another option epoxy putty drill 2 small holes either side off the broken parts mix some putty position the parts together and mould the putty around the brake pushing the putty into the holes when it cures it can be filed to shape
the finish will be slightly thicker than the original part but also stronger just remove paint and roughen area around break as well as the holes :-))
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Waterproof-Epoxy-Putty-Repair-Adhesive-Seals-Leaks-Pipes-fix-and-fill-holes-/321395086382?pt=UK_Crafts_Cardmaking_Scrapbooking_Glue_Tape_EH&hash=item4ad4a3d42e
-
Hi Guys
Just been out and measured the A frame in question. Each plastic leg is 9.5 x 2mm and come away from the hull at an angle.
As already stated for static display plasweld is more than man enough!
To use this in the water with a prop and shaft turning at 6 - 16000 rpm !
With a prop and shaft that are not perfectly balanced or worse bent !
Add to that the probability of hitting a twig in the water and the stresses invlved !
Get real ! This is a plastic kit made for static display. The only realistic chance is to make brass A frames, properly lined up with 'straight' shaft. The A frames should have tabs on the inside fixed to reinforcement.
Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but in my opinion anything else is only going to involve more wasted time/money and heartache !
longshanks