Model Boat Mayhem

Mess Deck: General Section => Tugs and Towing => Topic started by: shad3925 on November 21, 2015, 01:54:18 pm

Title: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: shad3925 on November 21, 2015, 01:54:18 pm

I had my heart set on a Model Slipway Yorkshireman and was about to order, I have been offered the Billing Smit Nederland kit at a very very good price.
I would be grateful for any comments and comparisons between the two before finally making up my mind
Reg

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Capt Podge on November 21, 2015, 02:10:45 pm

I've not had any experience with the Yorkshireman - the Billings Smit Nederland is very definitely an experienced builders kit, so I guess it's down to whether you feel comfortable with it.
 
There are a couple of threads currently running on here with regards to the Smit Nederland, including my own, so I'm somewhat biased. %)
 
Regards,
 
Ray.
 

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Capt Podge on November 21, 2015, 02:17:28 pm

Here's the links Reg - http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,52330.0.html (http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,52330.0.html)
 
or - http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,52968.0.html (http://www.modelboatmayhem.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,52968.0.html)
 
Regards,
 
Ray.
 

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: shad3925 on November 21, 2015, 02:19:46 pm

Thanks Ray.
Can you enlarge on experience needed for the Nederland.
Reg

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Capt Podge on November 21, 2015, 02:38:33 pm

Reg, the term "experienced" is used by the model kit suppliers to indicate the degree of difficulty involved to complete their models to a reasonable standard.
 
There were no build instructions with mine (good plans though) and I made a lot of mistakes on the way, finally completing the model after 5 years!
Of course, I had very little time available to me then, working away from home a lot.
 
As you will see on my thread, I'm rebuilding that same model and hoping to achieve a better standard this time around. :-)
 
Regards,
 
Ray.
 

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: GAZOU on November 21, 2015, 03:09:37 pm

The kit of Yorkshireman is accompanied with a very good note, an impossible to make a mistake, and the manufacturer of the kit is very available.
I would be you I would choose Yorkshireman

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: radiojoe on November 21, 2015, 04:03:10 pm

When in doubt get BOTH

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: shad3925 on November 21, 2015, 04:24:17 pm

Many thanks.
Apparently the newer versions come with a detailed instruction booklet showing every step of the construction.

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Capt Podge on November 21, 2015, 04:35:24 pm

Quote from: shad3925 on November 21, 2015, 04:24:17 pm

Many thanks.
Apparently the newer versions come with a detailed instruction booklet showing every step of the construction.

Maybe the manufactures are receiving / reacting to some feedback then...
 
Whatever you decide - Enjoy!
 
Regards,
 
Ray.
 

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: jarvo on November 22, 2015, 12:00:37 pm

HI Shad


I have built both kits, they do need a bit of nows to build but common sence and a look twice if it dont fit helps, anouther thing, Neddy is a slim hull and yorkie is a tubby hull, motors batteries etc size and weight, all need consideration.


If the Neddy is a lot cheaper then go fot that, Plastic hull or Glass hull, how clumsy are you, strong youkie??????


Hope this helps


Mark

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: jarvo on November 22, 2015, 12:05:22 pm

Sorry Shad


Got carried away, (some think it shoud be permanent!!!!) mixed the neddy and the Rotterdam in hull description. Have built the Rotter as well, Needy is a slightly smaller tug if a car boot size limit is needed, also the neddy should come out slightly lighter, espesialy if you go for batteries instead of lead balast, (take out the batteries)


Mark

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Fastfaz on November 22, 2015, 12:33:54 pm

     From experience with a Yorkshireman they are top heavy and difficult to get the ballast right even then dodgy in windy conditions. I would go for the Smit. Hope this helps.
       Cheers,
           Faz. :-)) :-)) :-)) :-)) :-)) :-)) :-))

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: shad3925 on November 22, 2015, 01:28:22 pm

Many thanks for all your replies it's been very helpful
Reg

Title: Re: Model Slipway Yorkshireman v Billing Smit Nederland tug
Post by: Capt Podge on November 22, 2015, 02:28:33 pm

Hello Reg - PM sent. :-))
 
Regards,
 
Ray.