Hi MikeK & P S II
Polyester resin exposed to air whilst curing, will give the sticky finish you mention. I don't know the technical reason for this but it is a fact. When the gel coat is used so it is exposed to the air during curing, you should add a tiny amount of (I think it's called) styrene wax to the mixture, which seals it to the air and stops the problem. When I used to do small chip type repairs to gel coats, I used to tape over with clear sticky tape during hardening, then remove and polish to a finish.
Bob