Model Boat Mayhem

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length.
Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: The recent ME Exhibition at Ascot  (Read 2236 times)

Glass half Full

  • Guest
The recent ME Exhibition at Ascot
« on: October 02, 2007, 07:53:30 pm »

Having attended the ME show, I felt some discussion was required as to the state of things regarding the marine element. I penned my thoughts and sent them to Model Boats Magazine for inclusion in their "All Points" hoping they would generate thought, discussion and eventual improvement. The reply from the editor was, I will not print your letter as it is inappropriate. Where has free speech gone, be it for or against a boating subject. Could it be the magazine and the sponsors of the show are too close? I reproduce my letter below, in the hope that this forum will elicit views from modellers who have visited the show. Good or bad, sock it to me.

Dear Sir,
I recently attended the Model Engineering Exhibition at its new home, Ascot Racecourse’s new atrium styled grandstand. The venue building is quite stunning, clean bright and well supplied with food and drink outlets. The exhibition was set out on three levels with thousands of exhibits on display. The ground floor was awash with trade stands. Between sessions manning our Luton boat club stand, I had a good look round. I and many others could not help but notice just how firmly the M.E. has reverted back to its core activity, the design and production of small mechanical engines in their many and varied forms. Several very well known collections were on display as were the S.M.E.E. All this bodes well for the future of model metal engineering.

Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for model boating at the M.E. Only three boat clubs attended, and not one marine trader thought it worthwhile taking trade space. Competition boats were not as well presented as in previous years. Even the judges I spoke to; said they were having a difficult time doing their job. Compared to the last three or so M.E. exhibitions, the boating contingent have become ever more isolated and Cinderella like. When speaking to many a marine modeller stopping at the Luton stand, they asked, where are the marine traders and the advertised boat pool and all the other boat clubs? A very good question and one the organizers should address and quickly. As clearly the marine modeller is loosing faith with this one. The marine medal competition is also looking isolated and loosing credibility with falling numbers of exhibits and so few new people entering. Should the M.E. organizers consider this state of affairs acceptable, with little or no further action required? Then it is time to consider the alternatives.

So before excommunicating me for heresy, take a moment to consider this. When part of an annual exhibition and competition is judged to be failing its competitors and supporters, it is not uncommon for those concerned to press for a change of sponsor and venue if matters are not put right. Modellers of such skill and eminence should be choosing a venue where a greater number of marine modellers congregate. They may not know about the rarefied air you model in, and it would be a perfect showcase for us to see, enjoy, aspire to your level, plus encourage us to take part in competition.

When entering a competition you are actively seeking conformation of your worth. What better place to achieve that position and ranking among your fellows, than at a vibrant International Model Show which enjoys an excellent marine following.  There are two established and expanding annual exhibitions available, Alexandra Place International Model Exhibition and Warwick International Model Boat Exhibition. There are of course issues of organization, judging, medals and trophies. Plus the all important support from those concerned. If competitors feel their endeavours will be judged by well established judges, that system of recognition of excellence is maintained. With no copyright on the use of medals, the Gold, Silver and Bronze awards remain valid. Clearly a move of this magnitude will have to be initially driven by the competitors, judges and other like minded influential people. For I genuinely believe, a move now would benefit and enhance the future of competitive marine modelling excellence.

Ken Gould.
 
Logged

Colin Bishop

  • Full Mayhemer
  • *****
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 12,515
  • Location: SW Surrey, UK
Re: The recent ME Exhibition at Ascot
« Reply #1 on: October 02, 2007, 08:24:25 pm »

Well Ken, I was asked to be a judge at Ascot (Kit Class) and I also assisted with the studio photography. I have been on the ME judging panel for more years than I care to remember.

However I don't work for Magicalia and can take an independent view myself.

Your letter to Model Boats makes a number of valid points but I can see why it was considered "inappropriate". No commercial organisation is going to print something which rubbishes their own efforts and suggests that rival organisations should be favoured instead. This wouldn't be down to the Editor to decide but his bosses. Magicalia publish Model Boats and they also organised the Exhibition so they aren't just close but one and the same! Free speech doesn't come into it.

I have made similar points to yourself privately and have been assured that they will be passed on to the organisers. Whether it will have any effect remains to be seen.

in my view the ME should aim to go back to where it was at Wembley, years ago, with the full range of modelling activities. Many modellers are interested in more than one aspect of the hobby and the more there is on show, the more people will come and the more likely traders will support it provided that they are not priced out by stand costs.

My personal view is that if you could combine the Alexandra Palace show with the Model Engineer Competition you would have the basis of a pretty decent London based show which would attract a lot of support. Unfortunately it seems that show organisers all want to do their own thing and are unwilling to co operate. Birchwood/Ellesmere Port is a good case in point. All this is not in the interests of modelling generally and I think that the various show organisers would benefit from having their heads knocked together. Traders would also benefit if there were fewer, more comprehensive shows to support. As it is they tend to be spread too thin.

There is a lot of room for improvement in respect of co operation by organisers for mutual benefit and we would all see the benefits ourselves. Will it happen? I don't know.

Colin



Logged

kiteman1

  • Full Mayhemer
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 177
  • Proud to be a part of the Model Boat Mayhem Forum.
Re: The recent ME Exhibition at Ascot
« Reply #2 on: October 02, 2007, 08:45:39 pm »

I am inclined to agree with your views, Ken, with respect to the model engineers versus the model boaters.  As one discipline overlaps the other by its very nature and as all sections of modelling are interdependent in some ways, I have a sneaking feeling that you may have inadvertantly stepped on someone's corns.  It may be that Magicalia Media by virtue of its publishing position are seeking to find a niche venue to keep under their control, whereas the Model Boat shows at Warwick and also the Warrington and Ellesmere Port shows in particular, are run by modellers for modellers.  There is a distinct difference between the two sections, ie, one to further its own interests and the other trying to keep model boating alive.  I hope that I'm wrong because our hobbies, whether in engineering or R/C need to work alongside each other.  Modellers as a section are getting older and we need to encourage rather than alienate, those who we would like to join our disciplines.  There don't, from what I've seen, seem to be a great number of younger people joining us.  

The other aspect of the ME show which you touched on was the lack of traders.  Could this have anything to do with the cost of hiring stands?  

Since I started to write these comments Colin has come in with some very valid remarks which I totally agree with.  I hope that heads can be knocked together and our hobby interests stitched together again.  Wembley and Ally Pally used to be superb venues in the Eighties.    

  
Logged

Bee

  • Guest
Re: The recent ME Exhibition at Ascot
« Reply #3 on: October 03, 2007, 09:20:43 pm »

 Publishing houses want to have a go with a magazine in any area that looks lucrative, splitting advertising revenue or overloading the advertisers. Then the mag wants to have its own show too. I stopped getting one mag that was always full of whining " my show is bigger than their show" in the editorial. (I see it's still happening in another thread on the forum).

It's not just modelling that gets this treatment.
For years a Landrover show has been held a Billing Aqadrome. It is a hopeless venue so the organisers booked up another location for this year. Then a bunch of idiots (from a rival mag - supprise) said can't let the tradition die, booked billing and killed the show at the new location as exhibitors had to choose between tradition and a beter site. Result - the cramped and expensive show was flooded and a mess.

As for transferring support to other shows, it should be remembered that ME and its show was the support for boating long before the newer specialist mags and shows started.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 

Page created in 0.373 seconds with 18 queries.